Custom Baits - Forum

General => General Discussion => Topic started by: AJayToRemember on 02/15/15 16:33 UTC

Title: Crappie Baits
Post by: AJayToRemember on 02/15/15 16:33 UTC
What with tax returns coming in sometime soon, I'm definitely gonna be getting a few new toys to play with. One of the molds I want to get is a mold to shoot baits for crappies, but I cannot decide on one to save my life. What would be the best choice?
Title: Re: Crappie Baits
Post by: 1boom on 02/15/15 16:37 UTC
I like the mayfly and 1.5" thump grub myself.
Title: Re: Crappie Baits
Post by: ctom on 02/15/15 17:29 UTC
1.5" Thump Grub hands down.
Title: Re: Crappie Baits
Post by: Muskygary on 02/15/15 17:41 UTC
Yes, 1.5 Thump grub. I just got one and thinking about getting one or two more. I know I'm GOING TO USE A LOT OF THOSE BAITS!
Title: Re: Crappie Baits
Post by: efishnc on 02/15/15 18:05 UTC
If you are going to be limited in your expenditures, I would recommend looking for baits with versatility; it's the best way to get the most (styles of) baits per dollar.  To me the mayfly is the clear winner as it is easily modified for three different looks all from the same mold... you get a spider looking front half, a minnow looking back half (if you rotate it 90 degrees), and the whole bait as a big juicy morsel.  (I haven't fished the whole bait as of yet, but I have done well on both halves through the ice.) 

The thumper fry is also fairly versatile, as you can pinch off the end of the tail to make it more of a pin style if the thump is too aggressive.
Title: Re: Crappie Baits
Post by: Jerry V on 02/15/15 19:51 UTC
So the 2.5" Mo Magic don't get no love any more ??   :'(
Title: Re: Crappie Baits
Post by: AJayToRemember on 02/15/15 22:00 UTC
The only reason I'm not looking at the thump grub series is because I've been kinda working on a design for something similar and making my own mold so I want to see how they turn out first. And Jerry I've actually been considering that one very strongly. Ever fished it personally? If so did it produce well? It certainly looks like it would.
Title: Re: Crappie Baits
Post by: 1boom on 02/15/15 23:27 UTC
The 2.5 mo is a nice little bait too but I have not fished it yet so I can not review it. My go to baits for crappie are the 1.5" thump grub and the mayfly. The white crappie here in central VA love the mayfly in a watermelon blue.
Title: Re: Crappie Baits
Post by: Botanophilia on 02/15/15 23:45 UTC
 I'd really like to pick up the 2" thumper swim fry.  And the thump grub looks great too.  2.5" MO Magic is my newest and I can't wait to fish it.
1.75" croaker is good.  1.75" carrot is pretty good.
2.25" twister tail is my go to, I need to pick up some 2.5" Kchubs to compare it to one of these days.
(http://custombaits.com/gallery/514-290115154058.jpeg)
Title: Re: Crappie Baits
Post by: bassinfool on 02/15/15 23:47 UTC
I rarely crappie fish but when I do I usually go with a twister grub or a little crappie tube.
Title: Re: Crappie Baits
Post by: Jerry V on 02/16/15 05:39 UTC
And Jerry I've actually been considering that one very strongly. Ever fished it personally? If so did it produce well? It certainly looks like it would.

I don't do a lot of crappie fishing but during the prototype mold stages of the 2.5" Mo Magic I fished it a few times.  I couldn't keep the crappie and blue gill off it.  They were traveling a long way (mostly crappies) and fighting over who was gonna be the next to smash it.  I had a blast.
Title: Re: Crappie Baits
Post by: MO QWACK on 02/16/15 09:01 UTC
My two crappie baits are the 1 Mo Magic  I'm a little bias on that  :P and the 2.5 fry I crappie fish 99.9 percent of the time. The mayfly is a very close 3rd not because the fish love mayFlys here but because it makes an awesome tube! I have the thump and about 15 other styles of crappie baits that collect dust just because those 3 baits fit every situation.
Title: Re: Crappie Baits
Post by: Thump Huntin on 02/16/15 09:58 UTC
Depends on where you live and what size bait works best. I'm in the south and would be looking at 2.5" - 3" baits. I have both the 2.5" and 3" Mo Magics and love them. Fixing to pull the trigger on the 2.5" Carrot and 2.5" Thump Grub.
Title: Re: Crappie Baits
Post by: Fatman on 02/16/15 10:19 UTC
Bass in the pond I fish love it!!!!!!!!!  I've had threats from people fishing around me to throw me in as they weren't catching and I have this jig and grub under a bobber and I'm catching fish.   I love tying jigs with all kinds of materials but I'm really liking it!!!!!
Title: Re: Crappie Baits
Post by: 1boom on 02/16/15 13:10 UTC
Hey mo... If you want to sell the thump I can clean the dust off it and put it to use... ????
Title: Re: Crappie Baits
Post by: AJayToRemember on 02/16/15 14:28 UTC
Well, probably gonna have to bite that little 2.5" bullet!! I don't fish for crappies a whole lot but I do enjoy it when I do, but I tend to find a lot of uses for the smaller crappie baits. Plus I do catch a lot of bluegill and warmouths for bait.