I am no expert by far but last weekend on Kitchen Lake in Oklahoma City me and a close friend of mine were both using a new pearl chartreuse 4" carrot in the same location roughly 15-20 feet apart for most of the day along the bank. He came in with a day total of 0 and I had managed to land 4 with the largest being 2.8. In my opinion the angler has a lot to do with the reactions the bait will receive, we were both using twin rods and reels rigged both by myself, same line, hook and rigging in the same location.
If you take 2 exact cars, put them on a track with one non-experienced driver and one pro, who do you think would win? (by no means calling myself a pro)
Drew