When I was remelting alot of old plastics, when I 1st got into this, I'd take like-colors and mix them. Any Watermelon, regardless of variations, got thrown in to what I call the "Watermelon Salad" mix. I shot some KILLER 3" Croakers with it. Same thing with various Pumpkin baits. I mixed a bunch of Pumpkin together, shot 3" Croakers in what I call "Bull Booger"...it's a transparent, light Brown "Pumpkin" color with different sizes of Black flake and some pieces of Flash Foil. If You've got the usual scraps on-hand, I'd look through them and see what I could cook up. If You'd want a little precision and repeatability, weigh what You add to the mix. I handload so I have scales for small quantities, to weigh in Grains, but my electronic scale also weighs in Grams. Weighing can add repeatability if You want to make more.