I know of and understand your large jig theory, but I don't hardly ever use a hook much larger than a size 4 on even the big river crappies and a size 6 is more the norm for me. I lose very darned few crappies, but then I'm not lift/swinging them into the boat. I'm pretty sure too that you catch a lot of big mouthed white crappies on those more southern waters and those could probably inhale a small anchor, hence you preference to larger hooks....eh?