Author Topic: Is Salt advantageous beyond sink rate?  (Read 10530 times)

Offline chase102798

  • Kicker
  • ****
  • Posts: 105
Is Salt advantageous beyond sink rate?
« on: 09/19/12 20:20 UTC »
Besides sink rate, is there any argument to putting salt in baits so that fish "hang on" longer? I'm not using any and I like the action and sink rate of my trailers without. Every bait manufacturer puts it in and claims that it produces a more appealing bait to the fish and I've heard it crunches like a real creature or tastes like blood, etc etc. I think it just makes baits less durable. What is the concensus?

Offline 412BaitCo

  • Lunker
  • *****
  • Posts: 612
    • 412BaitCo
Is Salt advantageous beyond sink rate?
« Reply #1 on: 09/19/12 20:45 UTC »
IMO I think there's a good chance that it makes them hold it longer just like scent does.

Offline MicroSpoons

  • Kicker
  • ****
  • Posts: 244
    • MicroSpoons
Re: Is Salt advantageous beyond sink rate?
« Reply #2 on: 09/19/12 21:59 UTC »
I think they  all use it just as a filler as the salt is cheaper then the plastisol, we all know they dont last as long with it so it also helps them sell more. 

Offline floridagrimp

  • Lunker
  • *****
  • Posts: 722
Re: Is Salt advantageous beyond sink rate?
« Reply #3 on: 09/19/12 22:23 UTC »
Why if I load up...say, a carrot with salt and a redfish with extremely high blood pressure bites it and has a stroke and assumes room temp!!!!  Am I liable for damages cause I made it??  Jason, for selling me the mold??  is the guy who started this thread liable also???    Could the State of Florida, even the DOJ get involved and file a class action suit on behalf of all Gulf Coast Redfish??

I think we all see where this could go.......developing....
"Be sure to fillet and re-grease!"

 "WATCH THE FOX, "fair and balanced" in a world filled with leftwing media types!
Obama's added 15 million to food stamp roles in 4 years (and growing).."If you pay folks to be poor then you'll have a lot of poor people"

Offline pjmcla

  • Lunker
  • *****
  • Posts: 1721
Re: Is Salt advantageous beyond sink rate?
« Reply #4 on: 09/19/12 22:33 UTC »
I think salt may entice a freshwater fish to hold the bait longer --  for a neutral feeding mode fish.  I personally think scent attractants are a better choice.  Particularly with neutral mode fish or especially in cold water.   

Offline MonteSS

  • Lunker
  • *****
  • Posts: 942
Re: Is Salt advantageous beyond sink rate?
« Reply #5 on: 09/20/12 02:08 UTC »
I think they  all use it just as a filler as the salt is cheaper then the plastisol, we all know they dont last as long with it so it also helps them sell more.

This is my thoughts too.

And I dont believe fish "taste"....they smell

....Bill

Offline ghostbaits

  • Lunker
  • *****
  • Posts: 1385
    • Home of Ghost Baits: Hand poured and Hand injected soft plastics
Re: Is Salt advantageous beyond sink rate?
« Reply #6 on: 09/20/12 09:01 UTC »
Why if I load up...say, a carrot with salt and a redfish with extremely high blood pressure bites it and has a stroke and assumes room temp!!!!  Am I liable for damages cause I made it??  Jason, for selling me the mold??  is the guy who started this thread liable also???    Could the State of Florida, even the DOJ get involved and file a class action suit on behalf of all Gulf Coast Redfish??

I think we all see where this could go.......developing....

I'll bet Denny sees an opening here...  :D

Class action redfish suit?????

Jim

Offline Denny Welch

  • Lunker
  • *****
  • Posts: 2377
    • Believe Baits
Re: Is Salt advantageous beyond sink rate?
« Reply #7 on: 09/20/12 10:11 UTC »
I've given this a lot of thought and I think we've got a pretty good case against Jason.  For a small fee, I'll start working on it right away.  Thank's for the referral, Jim.
Until next time.

Denny

denny@believebaits.com
www.believebaits.com

Offline JMason

  • Keeper
  • ***
  • Posts: 62
    • Beagle Creek Bait Company
Re: Is Salt advantageous beyond sink rate?
« Reply #8 on: 09/20/12 11:01 UTC »
I think they  all use it just as a filler as the salt is cheaper then the plastisol, we all know they dont last as long with it so it also helps them sell more.
X's 2

Offline andrewlamberson

  • Lunker
  • *****
  • Posts: 2463
Re: Is Salt advantageous beyond sink rate?
« Reply #9 on: 09/20/12 11:27 UTC »
I've ranted on this topic a couple times! :D

It's obviously personal opinion...and if it gives you confidences...then it works.....but...

Salt was added as a cheap filler to replace expensive plastic. It is a common practice in the plastic's industry (disclosure: I work for a high technology engineered plastics firm) to add "fillers" to displace expensive resins (plastic).

It make the baits significantly less durable ...and they sold more.

Some brilliant marketing type guy ...such as myself  8) ...came up with:
 "fish hold the bait longer"
"tastes like blood"
"Immediately seek medical attention if your erection lasts more than 4 hrs"
 (I bet the bell rang big time when the Marketing guy heard some Doctor/Lawyer/Regulatory person say that for the 1st time!!!)

.... to rationalize why they were making their baits so fragile that you could only catch one fish per!!!!!

There is little scientific proof that it makes a difference....but some may argue this based on "experience" on the water.

If you want to adjust your sink rate....use a heavier weight! If you want it to sink really slowly...use a lighter weight! If you want it to float...DON"T use salt! If you want it to sink very..very slowly....Don't use the salted ones.

Personally I don't like salt because:
1. I want to adjust the sink rate to what I want it to be
2. It makes the baits very fragile. One bass per bait is a rip off!
3. When the bass throws the bait I want it to float so I can go over and retrieve it and use it again...and again....
4. It causes hooks and lures to rust!!!!!
5. What if the bass don't like the taste of salt???
6.  Ummm ...ever wonder if bass have become conditioned to AVOID the salt smell??? After you've been wacked a few times by those salty tasting things....maybe they learn to avoid them???


Thank you for the opportunity to rant again! ;D
" You can't buy happiness...But you can buy fishing gear...and that's kind of the same thing"

Offline Justin9j

  • Lunker
  • *****
  • Posts: 1647
Is Salt advantageous beyond sink rate?
« Reply #10 on: 09/20/12 15:26 UTC »
I'm with Andy.

Offline JMason

  • Keeper
  • ***
  • Posts: 62
    • Beagle Creek Bait Company
Re: Is Salt advantageous beyond sink rate?
« Reply #11 on: 09/20/12 16:06 UTC »
Andy, you are 100% right on this. I really hate it when someone asks for salt in their baits. I think it kills the action and the durability of the bait. I do try to talk them out of it, and I sometimes succeed.

Offline chase102798

  • Kicker
  • ****
  • Posts: 105
Re: Is Salt advantageous beyond sink rate?
« Reply #12 on: 09/29/12 19:11 UTC »
you guys have sold me. Except for maybe some weightless senkos, no salt is my official party line. Thanks for all the info, rants, and legal advice ;)

Offline out on a ledge

  • Minnow
  • *
  • Posts: 9
Re: Is Salt advantageous beyond sink rate?
« Reply #13 on: 09/29/12 21:01 UTC »
I'm glad you started this topic because I was also wondering the same. No salt for me unless its for my beer. Lol

Offline 412BaitCo

  • Lunker
  • *****
  • Posts: 612
    • 412BaitCo
Is Salt advantageous beyond sink rate?
« Reply #14 on: 09/29/12 21:13 UTC »
Do you salt your beer so it goes down easier or so you hold onto it longer lol?