Thanks guys, I've done similar patterns by spinning deer hair around the collar but the deer hair is soft and doesn't offer the same resistance in the water as the fine rubber does. I tie it in first then stretch and cut the strands loose, I have tied it with loose strands but that takes even longer. The weed guard isn't really for weeds, it helps with limbs and light brush too but the main reason is it helps keep the jig from getting wedged in between rocks. The places I throw these are rock flats adjacent to wintering holes, the fish will leave the hole to go feed on these flats and there is a lot of chunk rock close together and that creates little gaps that can cause the jig to become wedged and if you over top to free it you end up ruining the spot so we break off snags but the weed guard really helps keep the snags down to a minimum. Later on in the fall or early winter, if we still have liquid water, I'll fish minnow profile buck tail patterns in the hole itself and those won't have a weed guard.