I should probably post this in a different thread but I think it really addresses this problem at its core.
This is one of the many current debates about plastic. Many choose a less expensive plastic, for different reasons (availability, etc.) but cost normally plays into it at some point. Things to consider to get the true cost of plastic: plastic cost, shipping, wasted plastic, your time, proper disposal of the containers, and something most don't want to bring up but I will - your health. If all of these are factored in the end result may not be what many expect.
To get a basis for your calculations you can just weigh your baits and plastic. I was talking to a guy that makes production crappie baits yesterday and he was telling me he was very unhappy with his current plastic, but that CC was beyond his budget. We did the math together and the cost of his baits with the less expensive plastic was $.09 vs CC at .11 - this is for an entire bag of baits - not one bait. Yes the cost of 5 gallons may be $20 different, but an entire bag of the end product was $.02 different. If he factors in his waste from bad injections, bubbles, time, the health of him and his son who helps him, it quickly becomes a no brainier (at least for me). Now this was his situation. If someone only made 20" worms, with an injection machine, that would be the other extreme and they would have an entirely different evaluation.
Caney Creek is a family business. My wife and both my boys work with me. Cost does matter, but with our plastic, coolant for the CNC, aluminum, and many other things we have gone through the same process, and every time have come to the same conclusion. Saving what looks like a few bucks is a marketing illusion that is created by companies with inferior products to try and trick us. Every time we have tried to save a few dollars it has cost us way more than what we saved. CNC coolant - tried several less expensive options, dulled a bunch of tools prematurely... The cost of any one of the tools more than covered the better coolant.
I'll stop. I know I've more than explained the point. With that said, there are a lot of options out there and I would encourage you to try them all and truly measure the actual cost: LC, MF, Ozark, Spike-It, Calhoun, MarChem, CC Crystal Clear, etc (please feel free to add others). You may be surprised by what you find. Every single one has good qualities. The traits I would measure are:
1. Usability
2. Health
3. Smoke
4. Stability
5. Smell
6. Clarity
7. Time
8. Cost
9. Shipping
10. Environmental Impact / Container disposal fees
You may find that more than one plastic really suits your needs. At the end of the day you have to use what works best for you and your situation. There's not one plastic I know of that is a perfect fit for all applications - not one.
Let the hunt begin...
Jason