I can't give any word on Green Pumpkin Green, but I do have the Caney Creek Green. I've only really started using it the last few weeks, and mostly to alter/change the color of remelts, shooting the 2" Glider. It's definitely a nice Green, seems like a Dark color but of course that really depends on how much is used and what it's added to. I can see Caney Creek Green with a little Red HiLite powder for a Crawfish color.