So after using this bait for a while I wanted to give a quick review. For jigging I catch more fish with the flutter lure. That said what I did not expect is how versatile the Shad Bait lure is. Sure they are good for jigging, but what I have found is they work much better as a casting/trolling lure! I poured a bunch of these out of tin, they have better action out of tin. I don't even use the front eye, I hook up to the eye on the back. It casts a mile, sinks fast, and has an awesome tight wiggle like a crankbait that you can feel in the rod tip. For my needs I like it better than spoons because it stays deeper, spoons tent to ride up the water column quickly.
This is quickly becoming my go to trolling lure too. It trolls deeper than any crankbait, and if I mark a fish very deep I just slow down a bit and down it goes. I am slamming lake trout trolling this lure, and am sure it is only a matter of time before a big brown trout falls for this method too.
If I can find one negative with this lure is that it hooks the line and gets tangled more often than other lures, but you can feel the difference right away, when you don't feel that tight wiggle, it is fouled and being pulled backward. Overall though, this lure is going to be on the end of my line more often than any other lure in my box when I need to fish 20+ feet down.