I didn't try it without a weight this weekend. I have before and didn't love it as much as the croaker. I had one rod with a croaker for when I wanted to test the top and the Big Foot for pitchin, fast buzzing under the surface, and hopping off the boat (Like you might with a jig). The strikes were good thumpers. The croaker was getting hit hard on the top by the juvenile bass (10-12 inches). Unfortunately, the smaller bass ruled the weekend which as nothing to do with the baits just the dynamic of where I was fishing. All and all it was fun because of the top water action.