If I had to choose between Hilites and Pearls, I'd take Hilites. I have the Hilite 6-pack, but also the Pearls in non-X2 liquid (labeled CCM), and I use them both. When I 1st started I had only Pearls but was unknowingly trying to get the effect of Hilites. Now that I work with both, I'm glad I have both because they both have an application. Try combining a Green Pumpkin base with equal (and small) amounts of White and Silver Pearls...killer natural minnow, other baitfish, or Sandeel. Some Silver hilite would apply very nicely when making "Fish Skin"...and Lord to'day, Hilites and Pearls make hand-POURS come alive with swirls and stripes...