Thank Yawl for the replies, Fella's!
With all the details of this trip, I do (at this point) believe that there's an effective attractant in (or on) those "old" worms...I think it's IN them. These were NOT the "Gulp" or "Alive", way-overly-expensive line of baits...these are made of typical, oil-based plastisol..."old" Powerbait Worms...Power Worms. We were within talking distance of each other, all day, and of course, fishing the same area. My presentation was the same as his, with the typical variations that go with trying to get a bite when it slows down. Now, like I said, I didn't have my Plastics Bag, so I had less options. I didn't have 1 worm, I didn't have any dark colors. Some of my thinking was Bait Testing, also.
What happened yesterday has sparked some major thinking. I believe it's more than Presentation. I believe it's more than JUST Color. I believe it's more than JUST Worm Body/Tail Style. It may be a combination of a few, or all, of these aspects...but I can't get passed the Gut Feeling that it's an Attractant. I REALLY wish I could show Yawl what happened, and how it happened. I've got ALOT of time on the water, and there is something to what happened yesterday.
Fire away, Bro's...